Season 5

1. Stewart Berkowitz: TV Props & Costumes

2. Shawn Sheridan: Toys

3. Kenneth Guinup: Weird Al

4. Telina Cuppari: Pizza

5. Gus Lopez: Star Wars

6. Jamie Knoll O’Neill: Survivor

7. Mark Short: Props and Costumes

8. Robert Baker: Toys

9. Morgan Richardson: Theme Parks

10. Mark Flitman: Pop Culture and Career Collector

11. Jennifer Klein: Props & Costumes

12. Tom Holbrook: Bozo The Clown

13. Joe Salzburg: Automobilia

14. James Zespy: Robots

15. Lisa: Dolls

16. Chris Christian: Movie Props & Costumes

17. Doc Mack: Arcade Games

18. Grant Deporter: Pop Culture & Sports

19. Shelley Jobe: Goofy

20. Marla Mogul: Wind Up Toys

21. Wally Wingert: Props & Costumes

22. Shon Abrahamson: Pearl Jam

23. Christopher Lee: LEGO

24. Ilene Wood: Handbags

25. Berry Bell: Jukeboxes

26. Rudy Munis: Masks